Sunday, December 27, 2020

Famous Folks - Alan Greenspan

#18

Who?

  • American economist
  • Chairman of the Federal Reserve from 1987 to 2006



Career and Personality

  • Came to the Federal Reserve Board from a consulting career
  • Subdued in public appearances, but media and followers considered him a rockstar
  • Criticized by Democratic leaders of Congress for increasing the deficit via his support for Social Security privatization and tax cuts
  • Called 'inflation hawk' because of his inflation policy, wherein critics claimed he was focusing on controlling prices rather than achieving full employment
  • Blamed in part for both the 2000 dot-com bubble and 2008 financial crisis
  • Known for being adept at gaining consensus among Fed board members on policy issues and for serving during one of the most severe economic crises of the late 20th century, the stock market crash of 1987


Views and Contributions

    • Greenspan was found by the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission to have contributed to the 2008 financial crisis for his failure to curtail subprime mortgage loans during the housing bubble
      • In a 2004 speech, he suggested that more homeowners should consider taking out adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) where the interest rate adjusts itself to prevailing market interest rates
      • He argued that the housing bubble was not a product of short term low-interest rates but rather a worldwide phenomenon caused by the progressive decline in long-term interest rates
      • When interest rates rose, it reset people's mortgages to higher payments causing even more distress for homeowners, exacerbating the impact of the crisis
    • He advocated for slashing interest rates after the 1987 stock market crash to prevent the economy from sinking into a depression
    • After the 9-11 World Trade Center attack, Greenspan led the FOMC to reduce the Fed funds rate from 3.5% to 3% and subsequently to 1%; despite this, the economy remained sluggish
    • The easy-money policies of the Fed during his tenure such as the Greenspan put have been suggested to be a leading cause of the dot-com bubble
      • He used the phrase "irrational exuberance" to imply a warning that the stock market might be overvalued


    Objectivism

    • Greenspan met novelist and philosopher Ayn Rand in the early 1950s, who nicknamed him "the undertaker" because of his penchant for dark clothing and reserved demeanor 
    • He was initially a logical positivist before he converted to Rand's philosophy of Objectivism by her associate Nathaniel Branden
    • During the 1950s and 1960ss Greenspan was a proponent of Objectivism and wrote essays and articles for Rand's 1966 book Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal


    The 'Greenspan Put'

    • Trading strategy popular during the 1990s and 2000s
    • Greenspan attempted to help the U.S. economy by actively using the federal funds rate as a lever for change
      • This encouraged excessive risk-taking leading to put options being lucrative
    • The 'Put' referred to a reliance on a stock market put option strategy that would aid investors in mitigating their losses, thus profiting from deflating market bubbles
    • It suggested that informed investors could expect the Fed to act predictably and make put option derivative strategies profitable during crises


    Fun Facts

    • Greenspan’s interest in facts and figures began at age 5 when he took a liking to recite baseball batting averages of players, which helped him figure out calculations in his head
    • Studied music at Juilliard and toured the country playing tenor sax and clarinet with The Henry Jerome Orchestra
    • Served under four presidents, starting with Ronald Reagan and ending with George W. Bush
    • Describes himself as a "lifelong libertarian Republican"


    Timeline of events

    • Stepped down as Federal Reserve chairman in 2006
    • Global financial markets began to unravel
    • Few financial institutions collapsed while governments experienced massive bailouts 
    • The worst economic downturn in three-quarters of a century ensued
    • Lots of people blamed Greenspan for some or all of this
    • He claimed to have found a flaw, so to speak, in how the world works, in a Congressional hearing in October 2008


    Awards and Honours

    • U.S. Senator John Heinz Award, 1976 (Greatest Public Service by an Appointed Official)
    • Fellow of the American Statistical Association, 1989
    • Commander of the Legion of Honour in France, 2000
    • Order of the British Empire (Civil), 2002
    • Dwight D. Eisenhower Medal for Leadership and Service, 2004
    • First recipient of the Harry S. Truman Medal for Economic Policy, 2005
    • Presidential Medal of Freedom, 2005 (Highest US civilian award)
    • Thomas Jefferson Foundation Medal in Citizen Leadership, 2007


    Quotes

    "It is not that humans have become any more greedy than in generations past. It is that the avenues to express greed had grown so enormously."

    "I know you think you understand what you thought I said but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant."

    "Government regulation cannot substitute for individual integrity."

    "Unless you are willing to compromise, society cannot live together."

    "I have found no greater satisfaction than achieving success through honest dealing and strict adherence to the view that, for you to gain, those you deal with should gain as well."

    "Anything that we can do to raise personal savings is very much in the interest of this country."

    "The true measure of a career is to be able to be content, even proud, that you succeeded through your own endeavors without leaving a trail of casualties in your wake."

    "I'm not denying that monopolies are terrible things, but I am denying that it is readily easy to resolve them through legislation of that nature."

    "The very nature of finance is that it cannot be profitable unless it is significantly leveraged... and as long as there is debt, there can be failure and contagion."

    "History has not dealt kindly with the aftermath of protracted periods of low-risk premiums."

    "Revolutions are something you see only in retrospect."


    Notes

    Harsh criticism of his tenure at Fed Reserve:

    Some of Greenspan’s harshest critics point to his earlier association with famed philosopher and novelist Ayn Rand. The essay he wrote for Rand, which also appeared in her book attacked the Federal Reserve and supported the gold standard to back the money.

    Former Congressman Ron Paul of Texas once confronted Greenspan about his turn away from Rand’s ideas of free-market economics and the gold standard, but Greenspan stood firm with his change of views on economics.

    Although Greenspan saw the nation go through tremendous economic growth through the 1980s and 1990s, his last five years as Fed chairman witnessed a 13% plunge in the S&P 500.

    Greenspan featured as one of the "25 People to Blame for the Financial Crisis" Time magazine article, which also suggested that Greenspan's advocation of low-interest rates combined with the unregulated financial system may have sparked the mortgage and banking crisis.


    Sunday, December 20, 2020

    Analysis of Franklin Templeton's Closure

     #17

    Overview

    • Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund closed 6 of its debt schemes in India:
    • Franklin India Low Duration Fund (62.8% of assets invested in bonds rated below A+, 45.76% rated AA)
    • Ultra Short Bond Fund (82.8% in AA rated, 23.9% in A rated)
    • Short Term Income Plan (58.6% in AA rated, 57.5% in A rated)
    • Credit Risk Fund (60% AA rated, 49.6% in A rated)
    • Dynamic Accrual Fund (52.7% in AA rated, 44% in A rated)
    • Income Opportunities Fund (63.97% in AA rated, 41% in A rated)

    Reasons

    • Illiquidity in bond markets
    • Severe redemption pressure
    • SEBI's opening of a window for AMCs to borrow to meet redemptions

    Cause

    COVID-19

    What happened?

    • The above 6 schemes of Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund (FTMF) took aggressive credit calls in their portfolios in the recent past
    • Despite getting higher returns by taking on these high risks, the debt funds and a few liquid funds (safest of the lot) experienced tremendous volatility
    • In the last 18 months due to COVID, worried investors withdrew money and exacerbated the problem

    Which led to

    • Shrinking of the portfolios
    • Funds left with a higher proportion of less liquid (riskier) investments
    • FTMF having to keep borrowing money to pay off the redemptions but reached the borrowing limit as per regulations

    Outcome

    Investors unable to:
    • Withdraw or transfer their existing investments
    • Start any SIP in those schemes
    • Make fresh investments

    Let's talk numbers

    Debt funds:
    • Outflow: Rs 1.94 lakh crore (March 2020)
    • Inflow: Rs 43,431.55 crore into liquid schemes, corporate bond funds, banking and PSU funds, overnight funds, and gilt funds (April 2020)
    Category-wise outflows:
    • Medium duration funds: Rs 6,363.53 crore
    • Short duration funds: Rs 2,309.05 crore
    • Money market funds: Rs 1,210.35 crore
    • Low duration funds: Rs 6,841.07 crore
    • Ultra-short duration funds: Rs 3,419.32 crore
    Credit risk funds:
    • Outflow: Rs 19,238.98 crore (April 2020)
    • Inflow: Rs 6,279.23 crore (March 2020)

    What all did FT try before winding up?

    Borrow
    • FTMF AMC borrowed continuously to fund redemption requirements
    • But were unable to repay the borrowings by selling bonds
    • Will lead to gross asset-liability mismatch in the long run

    Restrict redemptions
    • Current terms for restrictions under the regulatory framework:
      • Maximum suspension period of 10 working days limited to once in a 90-day cycle
      • AMC needs to honour redemptions up to Rs 2 lakh per day per investor
    • The above terms made this approach infeasible

    Elongate redemption payments
    • Redemptions pay-outs were being made on a T+1 basis with a maximum of 10 working days
    • This approach too was unviable because it would only handle the short-term liquidity issues and not the sustained impact of the crisis

    Distress Sale
    • In a distress sale, the AMC would have to sell the securities at a discount to meet redemption requests
    • If so, investors staying invested would have borne significant losses

    Winding up was the only forced choice for FTMF.

    So, when will the investors get their money?

    Once:
    • The macroeconomic situation improves
    • Cash-flow pains will be relieved
    • FTMF makes good on their debts
    • Investors are allowed to withdraw their investments
    • FT does an orderly sale of their investments in order to return the money to investors
    • FTMF communicates an exit strategy for their schemes

    Bright side

    Debt fund redemptions slowed after RBI announced a Rs 50,000 crore credit support for MFs

    FT can attempt to retrieve the value invested in those schemes either by selling the underlying assets (e.g. corporate bonds), or wait for them to reach maturity, when those companies will have to pay back what is owed to them.

    Sunday, December 13, 2020

    Article: Risk in MFs

    #16

    This post compares the risk between equity funds and debt funds.

    Risk: volatility aka fluctuation in price

    Equity

    • Equity funds are riskier in the short to medium term
    • They have a propensity to swing more intensely in either direction

    Debt

    • Two aspects of risk: interest risk, credit risk
    • Interest risk
      • Interest rates may move up or down
      • Rise in interest rates --> fall in bond prices (and vice-versa)
      • A fund comprising long-duration bonds is subject to high risk
    • Credit risk:
      • Risk of default by the bond issuer
      • Debt funds investing in low-rated paper are subject to credit risk

    Fund types and their risk grade

    Equity funds in increasing order of risk:

    • Aggressive hybrid funds (least risky) (35% of assets invested in debt)
    • Large companies (don’t fluctuate erratically)
    • Mid and small caps 
    • Thematic and sectoral funds (undertake theme-specific bets, hence riskiest)


    Debt funds in increasing order of risk:

    • Liquid funds (least risky)
    • Ultra short-duration funds
    • Short-duration funds
    • Medium-duration funds
    • Credit-risk funds
    • Dynamic-bond funds
    • Long-term gilt funds

    How to take risk into account while investing

    Solution: Diversify.

    • Invest across fund houses and schemes
      • This decreases fund-house-specific, fund-manager specific and scheme-specific risks
    • Lessen portfolio risk by investing in multi-cap equity funds


    Sunday, December 6, 2020

    Lessons from Freakonomics

    #15

    While you’ll find my latest book summary on the key takeaways from the book Freakonomics here, which I’ve also recommended as a good book here, let’s understand some of the other lessons mentioned in the book via simple anecdotes.

    Lesson 1:

    Economics is mostly about incentives, which can backfire if you don’t understand how they work

    Anecdote 1:

    There was a daycare that was subject to late pickups. Despite sending home notes and arguing in favour of having respect of children and their caretakers at home, there was no change. So, the daycare decided to send another note one day, saying that a financial penalty would be levied for late pickups. Instead of remedying the situation, the number of late pickups increased exponentially! This was because the guilt had been removed and the financial penalty was so low that the late pickup was now a perk accessible to most parents.


    Lesson 2:

    Men will lie about their height on dating websites due to information asymmetry

    Anecdote 2:

    Asymmetry of power refers to someone having or knowing considerably more than the another party. The ability to awe, intimidate, lie, or otherwise affect the outcome of a decision is vast. Susie’s love life moved from real life to the Internet. What was once known upfront became reported information. Though Susie checked several boxes declaring that she didn’t care about height, income, weight, or race, deep down she knew she did to some extent, just like the old times. Looks like her man too, adjusted his online response accordingly! What he lacked in reported stature, he made up for with charm and wit in person, as we would assume. Did Susie go on a second date? I guess we’ll never know.

    Lesson 3:

    Parenting experts are fear mongers who moonlight in product placement

    Anecdote 3:

    When experts rely on not knowing and use intimidation to defend their theory, some poor clueless parents fall prey to such tactics, as outlined below:

    Bob and Lucy bought car seats for $200! Statistics clearly show that despite buying expensive car seats, this does not actually save more lives. 

    They then purchased a 'family bed', since the salesman convinced them that they were the only parents who really cared. Unfortunately for them, they were unaware that all they had to do was advocate a parenting style that nurtured self-reliance and self-soothing. They were also oblivious to the below factors which do and do not correlate to higher test scores:

    Factors correlating to higher test scores

    1. Highly educated English-speaking parents with high socioeconomic status
    2. Low birth weight of their child
    3. Adopted child
    4. Parents involved in PTA
    5. Mother being 30+ at the time of their first child’s birth
    6. Child surrounded by books at home

    Factors not correlating with higher test scores

    1. Intact family who moved to a better neighbourhood recently
    2. Child watching television daily
    3. Regularly spanked child
    4. Mother not having gone to work between birth and kindergarten
    5. Parents reading to their child often